Place An Order

Order New York’s Best Cookies For Pickup and Delivery

Order Captain Cookie and the Milkman’s cookies, ice cream sandwiches, floats, and more. Available for pickup at our New York locations or for delivery.

You can also place a custom order on our Order Ahead page. 

Find Captain Cookie and the Milkman cookies and desserts on your favorite food delivery apps.

Pick up cookie from one of our NYC Captain Cookie and the Milkman locations.

Order ahead for delivery (if you want to place an order for >25 servings or are ordering at least one day in advance).

Cookies Aren’t the Only Thing We Deliver!

We offer a wide variety of tasty sweet treats in New York City and a cookie-of-the-month club shipped anywhere in the U.S.! Fill out the form below to learn more about our subscription boxes or to ask about custom orders by emailing