Captain Cookie & the Milkman serves up fresh baked cookies, ice cream sandwiches, milkshakes and other delicious desserts in its New York stores or by delivery right to your door!

Chocolate chip cookie


Just the Way You Love Them!

Captain Cookie treats are all made from scratch using our secret recipes, baked fresh daily! We also offer edible cookie dough straight from the jar!

Chocolate ice cream scoop

Fresh Ice Cream, Milk, and Milkshakes from Local Creameries

What’s more iconic than cookies and cream? We partner with local creameries to deliver the best quality ice cream, milk, and milkshakes.

Ice Cream Float

Sodas and Floats

A classic combo that never goes out of style, our sodas and floats will whisk you away from the daily doldrums.

Order your made-from-scratch cookies today!

Order fresh made cookies and other desserts for delivery or pickup in NYC.

Saving the World One Cookie at a Time

Baking delicious cookies for people across New York City is our passion, but that’s not the only reason we do it. We’re also on a mission to make the world a better place!

Many of our efforts to help our local communities focus on donations to local foodbanks and No Kid Hungry. We also help raise funds for local schools and organizations. Our customers can snack happily knowing they’re helping to end hunger in New York City and save the world one cookie at a time!

Cookies and milk

Our Origin Story

We developed a handful of knockout recipes for the cookies featured on our menu. These cookies are made-from-scratch using the finest ingredients. We’ve put everything into making your cookie the best you’ve ever had.

Explore Our Cookies

Chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, and so many more tantalizing flavors await. Come find your favorite flavors!

Cookies Aren’t the Only Thing We Deliver!

We offer a wide variety of tasty sweet treats in New York City and a cookie-of-the-month club shipped anywhere in the U.S.! Fill out the form below to learn more about our subscription boxes or to ask about custom orders by emailing